John Deere vs. Cub Cadet Lawn Tractor: Most homeowners despise mowing the lawn, but it’s a necessary evil if you want to keep your yard looking nice. Lawn tractors, however, have made this work more bearable, if not fun, for many individuals.
Two of the most popular brands of lawn tractors on the market are Cub Cadet and John Deere. But, which is the most effective lawn mower?
This article will pit these two turf titans against each other in a no-holds-barred Cub Cadet vs. John Deere Lawn Tractor Face-Off. Let’s get this party started!
John Deere vs. Cub Cadet Lawn Tractor Comparison
Consider the John Deere D130, which costs $1,900, and, Cub Cadet XT1 LT42, which costs $1,700 (above left),. Both are available at home improvement stores and offer a gorgeous cut. But which model is superior? To find out, Consumer Reports pitted them against one another in this lawn mower comparison.
John Deere vs. Cub Cadet Lawn Tractor Design
First things, let’s talk about the design of these two lawn tractors.
The John Deere D130 lawn tractor has a more classic look, with its signature green and yellow paint job. Its high-back seat provides excellent lumbar support, and the cruise control feature allows for easy mowing. The John Deere also has a cutting-edge Accel Deep deck, which delivers superior performance and a clean cut.
The Cub Cadet XT1 LT42 lawn tractor has a sleek and modern design that is sure to turn heads. Its ergonomic seat and steering wheel provides a comfortable ride, while the hydrostatic transmission allows for easy speed adjustments. The Cub Cadet also features a floating deck, which adjusts to the contours of your lawn for a precise cut every time.
Both the John Deere D130 and Cub Cadet XT1 LT42 cut exceptionally well in side-discharge mode and excelled in our bagging evaluation.
Our mulching test revealed the only noticeable difference. Here, the Cub Cadet has a tiny advantage, receiving a perfect score for shredding grass clippings into fine particles that sink into the ground and nourish the soil.
You will not be dissatisfied with the mulching performance of the Deere. (A mulching package costs between $30 and $60.)
winner: Cub Cadet XT1 LT42
Controls, Comfort, and Handling
Comfort shouldn’t be overlooked while purchasing a riding lawn mower. In some places, you may spend 50 hours or more on your tractor per season.
Both the John Deere D130 and Cub Cadet XT1 LT42 feature a comfortable and plush high-back seat, as well as an automated drive system (which adjusts the gearbox for speed) and washout apertures for washing under the cutting deck with a garden hose.
In our tests of braking, steering, turning, and stability, the Deere had a more smooth ride than the Cub Cadet. Yet, the change is marginal. And if you’re upgrading from a push mower, nearly every tractor in our ratings will seem like a significant upgrade.
winner: John Deere D130
According to surveys, approximately 22 percent of John Deere tractor models break down in their fourth year of operation. In contrast, 37% of those manufactured by Cub Cadet fail during the same time range.
The average repair cost for both brands is less than $100. If you are considering purchasing a lawn tractor, both the Cub Cadet XT1 and the John Deere D130 are excellent selections.
Both are inexpensive in comparison to other riding mowers. Similar in quality is their performance. Both provide comfort, maneuverability, and stability on level ground. Cub Cadet is a wonderful choice if you want a mulcher that runs on electricity and is of high quality.
Choose the John Deere model if you want equipment that runs on gasoline, is easier to manage, is slightly less expensive, and is slightly more dependable.
Possibly the most significant difference between john deere and cub cadet is the price. In general, Cub Cadet is the most cost-effective option, with riding mower prices ranging widely. law range lawn tractor models can be bought for between $1,500 to $2,000, while more expensive options range between $4,000 to $5,000.
John Deere is considerably more costly. Their average price for riding mowers exceeds $3,000 There are a few more affordable alternatives, but none that compare to Cub Cadet. Cub Cadet has the upper hand if you’re seeking for an economical and dependable riding mower.
Tie: John Deere for reliability; Cub Cadet for cost
- John Deere vs New Holland Tractors
- John Deere vs. Mahindra Tractors
- Kubota vs Yanmar
- Kubota Vs Massey Ferguson
In conclusion, both the John Deere D130 and Cub Cadet XT1 LT42 are excellent riding mowers. In fact, both are so exceptional and tied for first place in our rankings. In a category where models can easily reach $3,000, this is noteworthy.
As a result, this contest is a tie.
Choose the Deere if you prefer a model that is a little easier to manage and more dependable. Choose the Cub Cadet if you’d rather save a few hundred dollars or compost your grass clippings.
In any case, upgrading from a walk-behind mower to one of these tractors will leave you with a lush, evenly-cut lawn and plenty of free time this summer.